Noel Kasey has always had a soft spot for her grandmother's fortune-telling games. She also knows they're just that. Games. Until one night at a party when she pretends to read a man's future as a joke and sees his life play out like a movie, including a lucrative business tip and a very intimate moment—starring her.

An unbidden psychic vision would be enough to unnerve anyone, but for overly cautious Noel, it's downright terrifying. She gives the stranger the highlight reel (minus their supposed love story), then hightails it out of the party and back to her normal, safe life. But two years later, when Noel's life is turned upside down by family drama, the universe drops the stranger from the party back on her doorstep. Literally.

Jamie Bishop is convinced Noel is his long-lost guardian angel, sent to guide him on his newest business decision. Noel, however, wants nothing to do with the reunion until a friend reminds her that a man who she may already be fated to is the safest bet of them all. As the two explore the fateful connection that brought them together and new feelings that are brewing, Noel is faced with a question: Is the future made up of things that are or things that could be?